'The Power of Influence' eBook by The Cirqle, available now for free
Download free eBook
Download 'The Power of Influence' our free eBook
Most marketers still treat influencer marketing like a side hustle, a messy mix of gifting programs, spreadsheets, and scattered email threads. That approach may have worked five years ago when the channel was mostly about awareness. But in 2025, when creator marketing is expected to top $32B, the game has changed.
Here’s the contrarian truth: it’s not enough to “do influencer marketing” anymore. Every DTC brand is doing it. The real dividing line is how you run it.
And here’s the kicker: you can’t get there with spreadsheets. Spreadsheets don’t forecast RoAS, automate briefs, or push content into Spark Ads. They weren’t built for performance at scale.
Platforms like The Cirqle are the new infrastructure. They turn creators into a measurable, repeatable growth engine by giving you the same level of control, automation, and accountability you expect from Meta Ads Manager.
This post will break down:
For years, influencer marketing lived in the PR department. You mailed out product, hoped for a tag, and celebrated if it landed in someone’s Instagram Story. It was about “buzz,” not business.
That era is over.
Today, influencer marketing is a $32.55B industry (Influencer Marketing Hub, 2025) and one of the fastest-growing line items in the DTC marketing budget. But here’s the catch: brands aren’t increasing spend blindly. In fact, 71% of DTC brands grew budgets in 2025 only when they could prove ROI.
And the platforms have caught up. Meta, TikTok, and YouTube now treat creators as native ad units. Spark Ads, Partnership Ads, Branded Content Ads, these formats are engineered for scale and performance. In side-by-side tests, creator ads regularly outperform in-house creative on CTR, CPA, and RoAS.
The translation is clear: the performance team is in charge now. Creators are no longer fluff or “nice-to-have.” They are the most powerful, most scalable media asset in your growth playbook.
But here’s the rub: performance requires infrastructure. Without automation, predictive data, and real-time attribution, creator campaigns collapse under their own complexity. That’s why platforms like The Cirqle exist, to give influencer marketing the same rigor, repeatability, and performance standards as Meta Ads or Google Ads.
The Old Way
Running influencer marketing without a platform is like trying to run paid media in 2009. You’re stuck in a tangle of manual tasks that drain time and crush scalability:
This process doesn’t just take time, it kills momentum. A single campaign can eat up 80+ hours of manual work, leaving your team burned out and limiting how many creators you can activate. In the meantime, your competitors are already scaling.
The New Way
Platforms like The Cirqle collapse all that manual chaos into a single workflow. What used to take weeks now takes hours:
The impact is staggering: 80+ hours of manual setup reduced to less than 8.
Think of it this way: running influencer campaigns manually is like trying to manage Facebook Ads in Excel. Platforms like The Cirqle are the equivalent of Ads Manager for creators, turning what was once chaotic and unscalable into a disciplined, data-driven growth engine.
For most brands, the biggest time sink in influencer marketing isn’t content creation or campaign reporting, it’s simply finding the right creators. Teams waste 50% or more of their time scrolling feeds, chasing referrals, and manually vetting profiles.
And even then, the selection process is usually flawed. Too many brands still pick based on vanity metrics, follower counts, likes, or an “aesthetic fit.” The result? Overpaying for creators who don’t convert.
The Cirqle flips this model on its head.
With AI-powered discovery, you can go from a broad universe of potential creators to a curated shortlist of proven performers in seconds:
This isn’t guesswork, it’s predictive science. Instead of gambling on follower counts, you invest in creators with a data-backed probability of driving revenue.
Finding the right creators is only half the battle. The real test comes when you try to manage them at scale. Running one-off collaborations through email threads is manageable, but running 20, 50, or 200 creators in parallel? That’s where most teams break.
What does scale really demand?
Most brands try to duct-tape this workflow together with 5+ tools: Slack, Gmail, DocuSign, Google Sheets, PayPal. The result? Delays, errors, and campaigns that crawl instead of scale.
Here’s the truth: you don’t have a creator problem, you have an infrastructure problem.
That’s why The Cirqle replaces the chaos with a single streamlined system. Communication, contracts, payments, content approvals, and real-time reporting all live in one platform.
The impact? Speed, visibility, and consistency at scale. And critically, The Cirqle solves the industry’s biggest operational pain point: according to Social Snowball, 51.2% of brands say real-time tracking is their #1 influencer marketing challenge. With The Cirqle, real-time performance data isn’t a luxury, it’s the baseline.
Ask most marketing teams what slows them down in influencer campaigns, and they’ll talk about creator discovery or content approvals. But the truth is this: the “boring stuff” is where campaigns actually break.
Shipping products. Paying creators on time. Managing contracts. Filing tax documents.
Individually, these tasks don’t sound like deal-breakers. But at scale, when you’re running dozens of creators across multiple markets, they quickly become the single biggest drag on speed and efficiency. This is where most teams drown.
That’s why The Cirqle integrates the entire logistics layer into one seamless workflow:
The result? Campaigns launch faster, execution errors are eliminated, and, most importantly, creators get paid on time. That last point matters more than most brands realize. Timely payments keep creators loyal, professional, and motivated to overdeliver. Late payments, on the other hand, are one of the biggest reasons creators churn.
Here’s the takeaway: most brands don’t lose creators because of performance, they lose them because of process. Fixing fulfillment and payments isn’t just about efficiency. It’s about building long-term, high-performing creator partnerships that actually scale.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: most brands still measure influencer marketing with the wrong yardstick. They track impressions, likes, and engagement rates, metrics that might look good on a slide deck but don’t prove revenue impact.
And that’s why influencer marketing budgets historically struggled to scale. Performance teams don’t care about vanity metrics. They care about RoAS, CAC, CPA, and LTV. If you can’t measure those, you can’t justify spend.
This is where The Cirqle changes the game.
The platform provides real-time revenue attribution, not weeks later in a clunky report, but live, as campaigns run. You see exactly how each creator drives sales, across both organic and paid activations.
Core performance metrics include:
Example: Invest $30K in creators and generate $90K in attributed sales? That’s a 3:1 RoAS. With The Cirqle, this calculation isn’t a manual guess, it’s instant, reliable, and built into your dashboard.
The takeaway: influencer marketing doesn’t need new KPIs. It needs the same KPIs your performance team already uses. The Cirqle makes this possible, putting creators under the same accountability standards as Meta Ads, Google Ads, or email.
Most brands still think of influencer marketing as an organic play, paying for a post, crossing fingers, and waiting for engagement. But here’s the contrarian truth: organic reach is a bonus, not the business model.
The real unlock comes when you take creator content, the most trusted, thumb-stopping format in the feed, and run it as paid media. Spark Ads, Partnership Ads, UGC ads: these aren’t side tactics anymore. They’re the highest-performing ad units available on Meta and TikTok today.
With The Cirqle, you can:
This isn’t theory, it’s proven. Brands like Loop Earplugs used The Cirqle to amplify creator ads and achieved a 10% higher RoAS compared to BAU paid campaigns.
The takeaway: creators aren’t just content, they’re your most efficient paid media engine. With the right infrastructure, you can turn organic UGC into scalable, repeatable growth.
Loop used The Cirqle to identify high-performing creators, negotiate fair rates, and run Partnership Ads at scale. The result? 10% higher RoAS compared to their standard paid campaigns. Read full case study.
Lyma used The Cirqle’s ROI forecasting to confidently invest in premium creators while reducing risk. The campaign delivered outsized sales impact while keeping CAC in line. See success story.
Scaling influencer marketing isn’t about one-off posts or seasonal campaigns. The brands breaking through plateaus in 2025 run creator programs as flywheels, compounding performance over time, just like paid media or email.
Here’s the repeatable model top DTC operators are using:
1. Discover
Use predictive data and RoAS forecasts to identify creators most likely to drive sales, not just those with the biggest follower counts. With The Cirqle, discovery becomes a science, not a gamble.
2. Activate
Brief, contract, and launch campaigns seamlessly. Automated workflows ensure creators know exactly what to deliver, by when, with contracts and payments handled in-platform.
3. Amplify
Turn organic creator content into Spark Ads and Partnership Ads. Run it through Meta and TikTok Ads Manager with ad permissions secured automatically. Scale using the 20:20:20 rule (20 creators × 20 creatives × 20 lookalikes).
4. Measure
Track performance in real time: sales, RoAS, CAC, LTV. No vanity metrics, no lagging reports, just the same KPIs your performance team already uses.
5. Repeat
Double down on what works. Put top-performing creators on retainer to ensure a steady stream of high-performing content, while refreshing with new creators quarterly to keep the flywheel spinning.
The key insight: Unlike traditional one-off influencer campaigns, a flywheel compounds over time. Each cycle makes the next one stronger, creators get better at telling your story, paid ads get smarter, RoAS improves, and CAC drops.
That’s why the next billion-dollar DTC brands won’t treat creators as a tactic. They’ll treat them as a system.
Influencer marketing platforms aren’t a “nice-to-have” anymore, they’ve become the infrastructure of modern growth marketing. Just as no serious brand would run paid search or paid social without Ads Manager, no performance-driven team can afford to run influencer campaigns without a platform.
With The Cirqle, brands move from manual chaos to measurable growth:
Here’s the hard truth: if you’re still running influencer campaigns in spreadsheets, you’re not running performance marketing, you’re running chaos.
The brands that scale past $100M ARR are the ones treating creators like media, not one-off experiments. The Cirqle was built for exactly that: to turn creators into your most efficient, predictable, and profitable growth engine.
👉 Ready to see how The Cirqle can transform your influencer strategy? Schedule a demo today.
