Choosing the Right Influencer for Your Marketing Campaign

Choosing the Right Influencer for Your Marketing Campaign

Discover key insights on influencer marketing and tips on selecting the right influencer to boost your marketing campaign at
minute read
Mar 14, 2024

Influencer Marketing hinges on the notion of obtaining endorsements and product mentions from people who possess an expert level of knowledge or social influence in their field. Unlike the glaring spotlight of celebrity endorsements, Influencer Marketing allows businesses to tap into the trust, authenticity and respect garnered by individuals in their respective niches. This touches upon the crucial factor of authenticity - a standard that is highly valued in today's marketing world albeit subjective.

At the heart of this strategy lies the task of choosing the right influencer. This can be a daunting prospect considering the multitude of influencers covering a diverse range of interests, industries, and audiences. However, strategic navigation through this process can result in a positive, impactful influence on your brand's visibility, reach, and credibility. Furthermore, the chosen influencer becomes an extension of your brand, personifying its values and ethos in an engaging manner. Therefore, the alignment of the influencer’s image with the brand’s values becomes an important criterion for selection. In addition, we advice our clients to marry brand-fit with a set of critical metrics that help determine influencer fit for your brand. These metrics include: avg. engagement rate, avg. reach, avg. impressions and organic CPM's, aside from the demographic information that's included on our platform.

Conducting a diligent exploration of an influencer's credibility, relevance, reach, and resonance forms the crux of the process and lies in the analysis of the metrics aforementioned. Here, relevance encompasses the influencer's connection with the target audience and the compatibility of their content with your product or service narrative. Reach entails the scope of their fanbase while resonance refers to the engagement level they command within their follower base. Lastly, credibility ensures an influencer operates with clarity, honesty and an intrinsic commitment to quality content.

In conclusion, as online landscapes evolve, businesses must pivot their strategies to encapsulate effective techniques like Influencer Marketing. Striding forward with the right influencer who personifies the brand's values can prove instrumental in dictating its success. The brand-influencer alignment reinforces the brand's image in the eyes of the customers, leading to higher engagement levels and driving more successful marketing campaigns.

Determining the Appropriate Influencer Type

Understanding Influencer Categorization

Being at pace with influencers' categorization plays a pivotal role in adapting effective digital marketing strategies. The influencer community is diverse and can be broadly categorized into three types - micro, macro, and mega influencers.

Micro-influencers, with their follower count ranging roughly between 10,000 and 100,000, are often seen as relatable figures and can be tremendously effective in niche industry campaigns. Their smaller, dedicated audience lends an intimate, community feeling which results in higher engagement rates. The modest follower count does not detract from their impact, as they often generate content that is perceived as honest, genuine and trustworthy.

Macro-influencers, threading the line between celebrities and everyday influences, have a follower count ranging from 100,000 to 1 million. With their greater reach and professional approach to content, they bring a broad fanbase. Despite lower engagement rates than micro Influencers, their extensive reach makes them operate like small scale celebrities, useful for brand advocacy campaigns intending to reach a broader audience.

Mega influencers are the highest tier of social media influencers, often boasting follower counts beyond 1 million. The influence they wield over their follower base is colossal, and brands often leverage this for large scale influencer-powered advertising campaigns. Celebrities fall within this category, and their advocacy sparks a wide reach but with lesser engagement compared to the other categories. Their endorsement can instantly elevate a brand's recognition and social standing.

Each of these influencer categories possesses unique pros and cons. Micro-influencers offer dedicated engagement and cost-effectiveness but provide a narrower reach. Macro-influencers balance reach and engagement but can be expensive to secure collaborations with. Mega influencers bring unrivaled visibility and prestige to the table, but their collaborations often come with a hefty price tag, and their audience base may be less engaged.

A case in point is the successful influencer outreach program conducted by 'Secret Sales' leveraging micro-influencers. Secret Sales’s strategy of gifting product in exchange for promotion on influencers’ platforms enabled them to reach a more segmented audience and significantly boost their online presence, demonstrating the power of influencer marketing.

Assessing Influencer's Brand Alignment

The Need for Matching Brand Values

Creating authentic brand representation lays the foundation for a successful campaign. Recent studies have shown that consumers are more drawn to brands that share similar values with them. Hence, matching brand values with those of the influencers is paramount in modern digital marketing strategies.

Authentic representation emanates when influencers epitomize brand values, enabling them to communicate the brand story convincingly to their followers. This organic integration prompts product endorsement and positions the brand organically within the fabric of social conversation, making it more relatable to the audience. Opting for influencers whose values resonate with the brand promotes credibility and trust, which are key factors in the decision-making process of consumers.

Misalignment can potentially result in brand dilution, negative perception, consumer skepticism, or even product boycotts. Working with influencers who promote clashing values or represent a personality that doesn't gel with the brand can lead to adverse consequences, such as loss of customer loyalty, unfavorable associations, or a tarnished brand image.

An example to highlight the above is the influencer partnership between 'Pepsi' and Kendall Jenner. The campaign faced backlash due to its insensitive handling of social issues, demonstrating the risks of misaligned values and lack of authenticity, and emphasizing the need for careful, culturally aware promotional endeavors.

Assessing Past Performance and Collaborations

The past performance of creators, and understanding their previous impact on other brands, can be important levers to understand what they may potentially entail for yours. Two metrics are absolutely pivotal to assess as you select influencers: avg. engagement rate, avg. impressions p/post, avg. reach p/post and the organic CPM rate that the creator can drive for your business.

Negotiating and Maintaining the Relationship

Developing a Mutually Beneficial Contract

Once the appropriate influencer is selected for an influencer outreach program, the onboarding process begins with negotiations. A mutually beneficial contract outlines everything from expected deliverables, deadlines, packages to exclusivity clauses and payment terms. It essentially encapsulates the agreement between the influencer and the brand in all its entirety, and is a cornerstone of influencer marketing.

Key parameters include content frequency, format, engagement handling, and deadlines. Content frequency deals with the number of posts required, while format refers to whether the content should be videos, images, or blog posts. Engagement handling outlines the influencer's obligations to respond to comments or repost user-generated content.

Rates with influencers can be negotiated either per post or per partnership package. Packages can be created to incentivize frequent and consistent content. It's important to discuss with influencers what strategy works best for both parties by resharing your campaign brief, before agreeing to a contract. Of note, this process is entirely automated through The Cirqle, so it's nothing for you to worry about.

In a successful application of these principles, Scotch & Soda, a clothing retailer, involved several influencers on long-term contracts, resulting in a consistent and effective advocacy and influencers campaign. Their thoughtful contracts -automatically delivered through The Cirqle - and commitment to long-term relationships helped multiply their reach and firmly establish their standing in the industry.

Wrapping Up the Influencer Marketing Guide

With its unique ability to blend the traditional elements of marketing with the dynamic nature of social platforms, influencer marketing stands as an effective approach to brand advocacy, audience engagement and as a powerful agent for performance.

We explored influencer categories ranging from micro, with their dedicated, passionate following, to macro and mega influencers, boasting larger follower counts with broader reach and higher absolute rates but more effective CPMS's. The analysis of demographics and brand alignment remains a central part to selecting the right influencer and ensuring the ensuing campaign generates the desired impact. A clear understanding of these factors can help create powerful partnerships that drive brand awareness and credibility.

The importance of a mutually beneficial contract, its negotiation, and effective communication channels cannot be underestimated. A well-structured contract sets clear guidelines for both parties involved and serves as a foundation for a successful collaboration. Adopting professional management techniques can further cement the brand-influencer relationship.

Final Thoughts on Influencer Marketing

From the outset, the realm of influencer marketing may seem overwhelming, yet its potential is undeniable. A well-planned influencer marketing campaign has the power to boost a brand’s recognition, generate relevant traffic, engage with the target audience, and ultimately drive sales. It is an incredible tool that grants brands access to trusted voices with engaged audiences.

Influencers are no longer just a 'nice-to-have' addition to a marketing plan, but a necessity, more so in today’s age where consumers continually crave authenticity and highly personalized content. The key to capitalizing on influencer marketing lies in thoughtful strategy, choosing the right influencer, and nurturing that relationship. Through this, businesses can not only reach consumers but also engage with them in a meaningful and authentic way, driving success for both the influencer and the brand.

As this strategic form of marketing continues to evolve, businesses that adapt and align their strategies with this dynamic landscape will lead the pack, while audiences all over the world benefit from the enhanced brand experiences that influencer marketing campaigns provide.

The Cirqle

Discover why The Cirqle is the worlds #1 Influencer Marketing Platform.
Discover The Cirqle platform
Our Integrations
Now available

Globally Awarded Influencer Software

The Cirqle is ranked #1 by clients and influencers. Our software is packed with amazing features, workflows and technologies to save costs and drive ROI.
Vast experience
We've been in the industry for 8 years. The time when TikTok didn't exist and IG Stories were still dead. We know a thing or two about scaling influencer.
365 support
Our software does the heavy lifting for you. However, if you're in need of more help, we're always here.
Highly scalable
Scale the influencer channel cross channel, across markets, with many influencers.
API Permissions
We handle permissions between your brand and your creators through API's. Fast, reliable and secure.

Get started free

Unlimited access trial to kickstart your influencer marketing immediately with The Cirqle
Start free 7 day trial
Book demo